fbpx

Forced Air vs Baseboard Heating: The Good and Bad

Forced Air vs Baseboard Heating: The Good and Bad

Forced Air vs Baseboard Heating: The Good and Bad

Forced air heating and baseboard heating systems are two popular options for heating homes and office spaces.

Both have advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice for your home or workspace depends on various factors.

The difference between forced air heating systems and baseboard heating systems is that Forced air heating systems use a furnace and heat pump to distribute hot air through ducts while Baseboard heating systems use a boiler to generate hot water circulated through hot water pipes and into baseboards along the walls.

This article compares forced air and baseboard heating systems in detail through various factors to help you decide the best among them.

MellowPine is reader-supported. When you buy through links on my site, I may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Forced Air vs Baseboard Heating: Which is Better?

ParameterForced Air HeatingBaseboard Heating
WorkingUses furnaces to heat air and circulate it through ductsUses boiler water to heat the air and distribute it through pipes and baseboards
Installation SetupComplexEasy
Heat transfer efficiencyLessHigh
Temperature ControlIndependent control for large spaces.Precise control for single space
Effective Heating RangeLargeSmall
DuctworkHighMedium to low
Noise LevelHighLow
Air QualityHigh Low
Maintenance CostLowHigh
A quick comparison of forced air heating and baseboard heating

Difference in Heating Method

Furnace of a forced air heating system
Furnace of a forced air heating system (Source: Michiana Mechanical)

Forced air heating systems use a furnace or heat pump to heat air, which is then circulated throughout the space using a system of ducts.

Here, furnaces or heat pumps are generally powered by natural gas, propane, or electricity. It heats the air to a high temperature before sending it through the ducts.

The ducts are typically located in the walls, floor, or ceiling of a building, and they distribute the heated air to different areas of the space.

On the other hand, a Baseboard heating system uses a boiler to heat water.

The water is then circulated through a system of hot water pipes and into baseboards located along the walls of a building.

a baseboard heating system
A baseboard heater (Source: Basic HVAC by Aaron Lee)

The baseboards contain fins that transfer the heat from the hot water to the air in the room, warming up the space.

Baseboard systems are generally more effective at heating smaller, enclosed spaces.

Also, heating baseboards with hot water is more effective at warming up flooring materials like tile or concrete.

Ease of Setup and Installation

Pipes and electrical wires set up for a heating system
Pipes and electrical wires set up for a heating system

Forced air heating systems require a network of ducts to distribute the heated air throughout a building.

These ducts can be installed in the walls, floors, or ceiling, depending on the layout and construction of the building.

The furnace or heat pump that powers the system is usually installed in a basement, crawl space, or utility room and is connected to the ductwork with pipes or tubes.

Forced air heating systems also require a thermostat to control the temperature of the heated air and a filter to keep the air clean.

Installing a forced air heating system can be a complex and time-consuming process, requiring the expertise of a trained professional.

Choosing a reputable and experienced contractor is important to ensure that the system is installed correctly by following all safety standards.

Baseboard heating systems do not require ductwork, as the hot water is circulated directly through the baseboards.

The baseboards are installed along the walls of a room, and the hot water pipes run through the baseboards to transfer the heat.

The boiler that powers the system is usually installed in a basement, crawl space, or utility room and is connected to the baseboards with pipes.

Baseboard heating systems also require a thermostat to control the hot water temperature and a system to circulate the water through the pipes.

The installation of a baseboard heating system is typically less complex than a forced air heating system, as it does not require the installation of ductwork.

Heat Transfer Efficiency Comparison

Heat transfer efficiency refers to the effectiveness of a heating system at transferring heat from the source to the intended space.

A system with a high heat transfer efficiency will use less energy to heat a space, resulting in lower power bills.

Forced air heating systems are generally less efficient at transferring heat than baseboard heating systems, as some heat is lost through the ducts, especially if the ducts are poorly insulated or have leaks.

Additionally, the movement of air through the ducts can cause some of the heat to dissipate, reducing the overall heat transfer efficiency of the system.

On the other hand, baseboard heating systems generally transfer heat more efficiently. This is because the heat is transmitted directly from the hot water in the pipes to the baseboards, with minimal heat loss.

Also, baseboard heating systems do not require the movement of air, which can further improve their heat transfer efficiency.

Temperature Control Comparison

Temperature control refers to the ability of a heating system to maintain a consistent and comfortable level of heat in a space.

A system with good temperature control can accurately maintain the desired temperature.

At the same time, a system with poor temperature control may result in hot and cold spots within a space.

Forced air systems offer more flexibility in temperature control as they can independently control the temperature in different areas of a building.

In contrast, baseboard systems offer more precise temperature control throughout the building.

Effective Heating Range Comparison

Effective heating range refers to the size of an area that a particular heating system can effectively heat.

A system with a larger effective heating range will be able to heat a larger area, while a system with a smaller effective heating range may struggle to heat a large or open space.

Forced air heating systems generally heat a larger area than baseboard heating systems since the heated air is blown through the ducts to various rooms of a building, allowing for more widespread heating.

Additionally, forced air heating systems can be used in conjunction with air conditioning systems, allowing for heating and cooling capabilities in a single system.

On the other hand, baseboard heating systems are generally less effective at heating a large or open area.

This is because the heat is transferred directly from the hot water in the pipes to the baseboards. As a result, the heat tends to rise to the ceiling rather than being distributed evenly at floor level.

Baseboard heating systems are generally more effective at heating smaller, enclosed spaces.

Ductwork Requirement Comparison

Ductwork for a heating system
Ductwork for a heating system

Forced air heating systems require a network of ducts to distribute the heated air throughout a building.

The installation of ductwork can be complex and requires the expertise of a trained professional.

Additionally, it is essential to properly maintain the ductwork to prevent leaks and ensure that the system is operating at its peak efficiency.

Baseboard heating systems do not require ductwork, as the hot water is circulated directly through the baseboards.

Noise Levels Comparison

Forced air heating systems generally produce more noise than baseboard heating systems. This is due to forced air movement through the ducts.

Additionally, forced air systems often have a furnace or heat pump that generates noise.

On the other hand, baseboard heating systems are much quieter than forced air systems as they do not require air movement. They transfer the heat directly from the hot water in the pipes to the baseboards.

The noise level of a forced air and baseboard system can vary based on the size and power of the furnace or heat pump, the condition of the ductwork, and the system's overall design.

Air Quality Comparison

Forced air heating systems can potentially have a higher toxicity level than baseboard heating systems as they rely on a furnace or heat pump to generate heat, which can release toxins into the air.

The most common toxins released by forced air systems are carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides, which can be harmful if inhaled in large amounts.

It requires a filter to keep the air clean, and it is essential to regularly maintain and replace the filter to reduce the risk of toxins being released into the air.

On the other hand, baseboard heating systems are generally much less toxic than forced air systems as they use a boiler to heat water, which does not release toxins into the air.

Cost Comparison

In terms of buying cost, forced air and baseboard heating systems are similarly priced.

The cost of purchasing, installing, and maintaining a heating system will depend on the size of the building and the number of partitions.

Forced air heating systems generally have a higher maintenance cost than baseboard heating systems as they rely on a network of ducts to distribute the heated air, which can be costly to install and maintain.

On the other hand, baseboard heating systems generally have a lower maintenance cost than forced air systems as they do not require ductwork, which can be a significant maintenance cost for forced air systems.

Baseboard systems also do not require regular cleaning and maintenance as they use a boiler to heat the water.

However, their water can become corrosive to the pipes over time. So you'll have to regularly ensure that the water is free of corrosive contaminants to prevent leaks in the system that can be costly to repair.

Pros and Cons of Forced Air and Baseboard Heating

Forced Air System

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Can effectively heat large or open spacesExpensive to install and maintain due to the need for ductwork
Much more control over temperature using the zoning systemLess effective at warming up flooring materials like tile or concrete
More efficient heatingLouder and more intrusive than baseboard systems
Uses air filters to improve indoor air qualityAir leakage in the ductwork can reduce its efficiency
Pros and cons of forced air heating compared to baseboard heating

Baseboard Heating System

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Can effectively heat smaller, enclosed spacesExpensive to install and maintain due to the need for hot water pipes and a boiler
More effective at warming up flooring materials like tile or concreteNot as effective at heating large or open spaces
Typically quieter and less intrusive than forced air systemsCan't control the temperature in different areas of a building
Pros and cons of baseboard heating compared to forced air heating

Different Types of Forced Air and Baseboard Heating Systems

Types of forced air and baseboard heating systems
Types of forced air and baseboard heating systems

You have choices in forced air heating systems and baseboard heating systems.

Types of Forced Air Heating Systems

Furnaces

Furnace-based forced air heating systems are the most commonly used forced air heating system.

They work by burning fuel (natural gas, propane, or oil) to heat air, which is then blown through the ducts and into the various rooms of a building.

Heat Pumps

Forced air heating systems that employ an electric heat pump move heat from one location to another, making them a more efficient and eco-friendly option for heating and cooling.

There are two types of heat pumps: air-source heat pumps, which transfer heat from the air outside to the inside of a building, and geothermal heat pumps, which move heat from the ground to the interior of a building.

Boilers

Boilers are similar to furnaces as they use a fuel source (usually natural gas or oil) to heat air, but instead of blowing the air through ducts, they use radiators or baseboards to transfer the heat to a room.

You can use boilers to heat water for domestic use and heat a space.

Types of baseboard heating systems

Hydronic Baseboard Heating

Hydronic baseboard heating systems use hot water circulated through pipes to heat a space. The water is heated by a boiler, which can be powered by natural gas, oil, or electricity.

Electric Baseboard Heating

Electric baseboard heating systems use electricity to heat a space. They do not need any boiler or special piping, making them a simpler and more affordable option for homes and office spaces.

Things to Consider When Purchasing a Heating System

Before purchasing a new heating system, consider the following factors to ensure the system is the right fit for your application.

Size and Layout of your Space

The size and layout of the space will be the first factor to consider when choosing a heating system.

Forced air heating systems are generally more effective at heating a large space like a conference hall.

In contrast, baseboard heating systems are more effective at heating smaller spaces like a bedroom.

Cost

Considering a particular system's upfront and ongoing costs is essential when deciding which system is best for a home or office space.

Geothermal forced air heating systems are the most affordable in the long term, but their initial installation cost is very high.

Type of House Flooring

The type of flooring will also decide which system is best for you.

Forced air systems can blow hot air under the floor, benefiting spaces with tile, concrete, or other hard floorings.

On the other hand, baseboard systems heat the air directly and can be more effective at warming up carpeted or wood flooring.

Heat output

When choosing a heating system, it is important to consider the heat output of a particular system.

The heat output of a heating system refers to the amount of heat a heating system can produce.

Forced air heating systems generally produce a higher heat output than baseboard heating systems. This is what makes it more effective at heating large spaces.

Internal Thermostats

A thermostat installed on the wall
A thermostat

It is essential to consider the location and convenience of the thermostat when deciding on a heating system, as it determines how much control you have over the temperature.

Both forced air and baseboard heating systems have internal thermostats but have differences in installation.

Forced air heating systems typically have a thermostat installed on a room's wall.

It monitors the room's temperature and sends a signal to the furnace or heat pump to turn on or off as needed to maintain the desired temperature.

Some forced air systems also have a zoning system, which allows for separate temperature control in different areas of a building.

This can be very useful for larger spaces or for those who want to control the temperature of different parts of a building independently.

Baseboard heating systems typically have a thermostat that is installed on the baseboard.

Still, it does not offer the ability to control the temperature in different areas of a building, as the heat is transferred directly from the hot water in the pipes to the baseboards.

Final Thoughts: Which is Better?

The choice between a forced air heating system and a baseboard heating system will depend on a variety of factors, like the size and layout of the building, the type of flooring, the heat output of the system, and the convenience of the internal thermostat.

Forced air heating systems are generally more effective at heating large or open spaces, and they can control the temperature in different areas of a building independently through a zoning system.

They are typically more efficient at heating the air in space as it circulates throughout the room.

However, forced air systems may be more expensive to install and maintain due to the need for ductwork, and they can be less effective at warming up flooring materials like tile or concrete.

In such cases, a baseboard heating system is more efficient as they use hot water to heat the baseboards. Also, they are better at heating smaller, enclosed spaces.

In addition, baseboard heating systems are typically quieter and less intrusive than forced air systems.

However, baseboard systems may be more expensive to install and maintain due to the need for extensive hot water pipe circuits, as they are not as effective at heating large or open spaces.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How long does forced air heating last?

The forced air furnace can last for 15 to 30 years. To maintain the efficiency of a forced air furnace, you'll have to hire a professional technician to run the maintenance and functional repairs once every year.

How long does baseboard heating last?

The commercial life expectancy of baseboard heaters is around 20 years, but with proper care and maintenance, the system can last longer than 20 years.

What thermostat temperature should I set in winter?

The ideal thermostat temperature recommended by the US government for winter is 68 degrees Fahrenheit. Also, it's best to lower the temperature to around 65 degrees Fahrenheit for better thermoregulation for your body.

About John

Hey I'm John. I write about Manufacturing, Metalworking, CNCs and Lasers at Mellowpine. If you have any questions related to CNCs or Lasers, I'd be happy to answer them. Reach me at mail@mellowpine.com

DIY Profile
John

Hey I'm John. I write about Manufacturing, Metalworking, CNCs and Lasers at Mellowpine. If you have any questions related to CNCs or Lasers, I'd be happy to answer them. Reach me at mail@mellowpine.com

Connect With Me

Related Posts

Comments

The comments are closed.